Fantastic Reviews: Battle of the Books, Winter 2012

for the rules, click here
click on the book covers to read more about each book in the book battle reviews

  FIRST ROUND SECOND ROUND SEMIFINALS FINALS WINNER
                                               
When We Were Executioners cover J.M. McDermott  
When We Were Executioners  
  Eyes Like Leaves cover Charles de Lint  
  Eyes Like Leaves  
Eyes Like Leaves cover Charles de Lint
Eyes Like Leaves*  
  Eyes Like Leaves cover Charles de Lint  
  Eyes Like Leaves  
The Isis Collar cover Cat Adams  
The Isis Collar  
  The Scar cover Sergey & Marina Dyachenko
  The Scar  
The Scar cover Sergey & Marina Dyachenko
The Scar  
  Eyes Like Leaves cover Charles de Lint  
  Eyes Like Leaves     
Gamers cover Thomas K. Carpenter  
Gamers  
 

Shadows in Flight cover

Orson Scott Card
  Shadows in Flight  
Shadows in Flight cover Orson Scott Card
Shadows in Flight*  
 

Shadows in Flight cover

Orson Scott Card 
  Shadows in Flight  
Jane Carver of Waar Nathan Long  
Jane Carver of Waar  
  Sisterhood of Dune cover Brian Herbert &
Kevin J. Anderson
  Sisterhood of Dune    
Sisterhood of Dune cover Brian Herbert &
Kevin J. Anderson
Sisterhood of Dune  
Range of Ghosts cover Elizabeth Bear
Range of Ghosts
Thief's Covenant cover Ari Marmell  
Thief's Covenant  
  Thief's Covenant cover Ari Marmell  
  Thief's Covenant  
Expedition to the Mountains of the Moon cover Mark Hodder
Expedition to the Mountains of the Moon  
  And Blue Skies from Pain cover Stina Leicht  
  And Blue Skies from Pain  
And Blue Skies from Pain cover Stina Leicht  
And Blue Skies from Pain*  
 

And Blue Skies from Pain cover

Stina Leicht
  And Blue Skies from Pain  
Boneyards cover Kristine Kathryn Rusch
Boneyards  
  Range of Ghosts cover Elizabeth Bear
  Range of Ghosts  
Range of Ghosts cover Elizabeth Bear  
Range of Ghosts*  
 

Range of Ghosts cover

Elizabeth Bear
  Range of Ghosts  
Jack of Ravens cover Mark Chadbourn
Jack of Ravens  
  Range of Ghosts cover Elizabeth Bear
  Range of Ghosts  
The Darkening Dream cover Andy Gavin  
The Darkening Dream  
 

The Pillars of Hercules cover

David Constantine
  The Pillars of Hercules  
The Pillars of Hercules cover David Constantine
The Pillars of Hercules  

* = "seeded" books

This page was last updated - 24 January 2013